Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Home / Opinion Digests (page 5) /

Opinion Digests

Real property – Lead paint – Limitations

A complaint alleging that the defendant seller of real property violated a federal statute by not disclosing the presence of lead paint must be dismissed as untimely because by the time of the closing in 2003 the plaintiff buyer should ...

Read More »

Products liability – Lupron – Settlement

A U.S. District Court judge presiding over a Lupron class action that was settled for $150 million committed no abuse of discretion in distribution $11.4 million in unclaimed funds to the Dana Farber/Harvard Cancer Center and the Prostate Cancer Foundation ...

Read More »

Products liability – Drug – Preemption – Design defect

Design defect claims against generic drug manufacturers are not preempted by the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act. Bartlett, et al. v. Mutual Pharmaceutical Company, Inc., et al. (Lawyers Weekly No. 01-117-12) (27 pages) (Boudin, J.) (1st Circuit) Appealed from ...

Read More »

Fraud – False Claims Act

Where a relator brought a False Claims Act suit alleging that the defendants submitted an application to the National Institute on Aging for research on Alzheimer’s disease which relied on falsified data, an award of summary judgment for the defendants ...

Read More »

Employment – FLSA – Pleading

Plaintiffs should be allowed to amend their Fair Labor Standards Act complaint seeking compensation for work performed during their meal breaks, for work performed before and after shifts and for time spent attending training sessions. Pruell, et al. v. Caritas ...

Read More »

Contract – Computer programs – Health care

Where a U.S. magistrate judge awarded a plaintiff $778,889 in damages on a claim of breach of contract, the defendant has not set forth a convincing basis for overturning the judge’s decision as to liability or damages. Amicas, Inc. v. ...

Read More »

Consumer protection – G.L.c. 93A – Price-fixing scheme

Where a G.L.c. 93A complaint over an alleged price-fixing scheme was dismissed, the dismissal order must be reversed, as the plaintiff plausibly alleged economic harm. Liu v. Amerco, et al. (Lawyers Weekly No. 01-119-12) (17 pages) (Boudin, J.) (1st Circuit) ...

Read More »

Civil practice – Judicial estoppel – Bankruptcy

Where defendants were awarded summary judgment on judicial estoppel grounds, that was proper in light of the plaintiffs’ failure to disclose the existence of their claims in the course of a bankruptcy proceeding. Guay, et al. v. Burak, et al. ...

Read More »

Banks and banking Limitations – Check

Where a law firm, which was held liable over a fraudulent check, brought suit against a defendant bank, a judgment for the bank must be affirmed on statute of limitations grounds. Aresty International Law Firm, P.C. v. Citibank, N.A. (Lawyers ...

Read More »

Exemptions – Specific dollar amount

Where debtors claimed exemptions in 100 percent of the full market value of their residence and car, an objection filed by the Chapter 13 trustee was properly sustained based on Schwab v. Reilly, 130 S. Ct. 2652 (2010).

Read More »